RSS Feed

The Quotations of Chairman Eddie.

Posted on

Those of you who came here because Neck Pickup won Best Music Blog in the recent Morning Call contest are about to learn that I write other stuff when I feel like it.

The National Baseball Hall of Fame has soy-bombed all my foreseeable free time with a new website called Diamond Mines.

It’s all about scouts and scouting, and it includes thousands of searchable scouting reports — real commentary by real scouts on real players, some of it going back as far as the 1950s.

A lot of it is mundane, but some of it is fascinating. I’ve already seen one player ragged on for needing a haircut.

The scouts occasionally tackle off-field issues as well. One player is rumored to have abused drugs in high school (“CHECK SOCIAL PROBLEM!” admonishes a scouting report), while another “could be a psycho.”

I’ve acquired a particular fondness for the reports of Eddie Bockman, a former big-leaguer who scouted for the Phillies and Marlins for more than 30 years. Bockman, who died in 2011, had a capacity for tartly but creatively summing up a player’s talents.

Some high points of Bockman’s oeuvre:

Chili Davis, 1989: “A waste of talent. Dog.”

Floyd Bannister, 1991: “Doesn’t look like a year in Japan has helped him – maybe financially.”

Matt Alexander, 1976: “As soon as one of the bigger donkies gets on base, he is used.”

Mel Hall, 1989: “Dead weight. Let George have him.” (Editor’s note: George Steinbrenner, presumably.)

Dave Bennett, 1966: “Thinks he has a sore arm.”

Mike Bielecki, 1991: “Might have a secret pitch that umpires can see. A little wet, grease, or what ever.”

Dave Smith, 1991: “Not saying he is legal in everything he does, but right now he is getting away with it.”

Bobby Bonds, 1966: “Needs a lot of work.”

Alan Gallagher, 1966: “Goofy but can play baseball.”

Cesar Gutierrez, 1966: “Check his past records.”

Andy Allanson, 1989: “Big guy, little poop.”  (Editor’s note: He meant “pop,” presumably.)

Joe Charboneau, 1976: “No problems with him, on the field or off.”

Willie Crawford, 1964: “He can run now, but with a few years of good eating, he might get a little heavy.”

Rollie Fingers, 1976: “Has some larceny in his sole, and this makes him the competitor he is.” (sic)

Ed Bays, 1966: “Lot of mouth.”

Greg Gross, 1991: “Trying a comeback. Too little toolate!” (sic)

Odell Jones, 1982: “Does some things a High School kid would do. Gets lost on the mound.”

Randy Lerch, 1973: “Not much hanging on his bones, but has versatile ability.”

Frank Rubino, 1967: “Clubhouse lawyer.”

Kevin Mitchell, 1990: “Makeup a little negative. Needs guidance on social life. Outside of this he will hit some home runs and knock in runs. Amen.”

Bill North, 1976: “Be sure everyone runs balls out that are hit to him. No telling what he might do with it. Not a good outfielder.”

Kevin Wickander, 1989: “Loose liver??”

Carmelo Martinez, 1989: “What you see, what you get.”

Rick Reuschel, 1989: “Weight the same. Height the same. Delivery the same. Stuff the same. Only thing different – one year older.”


One response »

  1. Enjoyed your post on Eddie Bockman. Was a great friend from 1995-2011.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: